The island's namesake fruity rum punch did not disappoint, particularly when sipped on the sands with THAT view. We weren't staying at this hotel, but were able to buy drinks from its bar. The beaches here are public, remember!
NYC Food Itineraries
NEW! Let us do the heavy lifting on your next trip to NYC: Check out our new downloadable one-day NYC eating itineraries, or email us for a custom multiday itinerary.