It’s the end of the LIRR line; the very eastern tip of Long Island jutting out into the teeming Atlantic, much closer to New England (by ferry) than New York City, 120 miles away—and it indeed feels far away from anything resembling hustle and bustle. Long the laid-back, clam-shack-dotted, surfer-friendly alternative to the posh Hamptons, Montauk is ruggedly beautiful year-round (though certainly quieter in the winter). Recent years have brought more modern accoutrements, with big-name Manhattan hoteliers and the like renovating old-school restaurants and bars into hip establishments, but the surfers and fishermen aren’t going anywhere. And while Montauk has its fair share of celebrity-spottings and jaw-dropping mansions, the area’s six state parks remain well protected against rampant development. So don’t worry about the “Hamptonization” of Montauk too much. You should be more concerned with choosing your next meal—soft-shell crab sandwich or local fish tacos?—whilst debating another ocean swim versus cliff hike. This is the summertime life.
Montauk, Long Island
Montauk, Long Island Food + Travel Guide
Essential Dishes
What to Eat in Montauk, Long Island
Activity Tips
How to Burn It Off in Montauk, Long Island
Aside from the calories (we hope) you’ll expend swimming, bodysurfing, and fighting ocean currents (watch those lifeguards!)—plus the aforementioned $10 morning yoga class at the East Deck Motel—here are some more ways to work off a few days of fried fish and beer.
BIKE
Ditch your car for the weekend and rent a bike: You’ll still get everywhere you want to go within 20 minutes and you’ll avoid the hassle of beach parking. Rentals at Montauk Bike Shop (725A Montauk Hwy, map) from $35.99/day; ask the staff about their “secret” maps and routes.
Read MoreAccommodations
Where to Stay in Montauk, Long Island
The family-owned, locally iconic East Deck Motel (40 Deforest Rd., map), its low-lying L-shape and wood-paneled rooms a product of the 1950s, offers unpretentious beachfront accommodation mere steps from the excellent surf beach Ditch Plains, its famous jetty break and trusted shore fishing (plus the esteemed food truck, the Ditch Witch). There’s also a pool, breezy decks, and outdoor morning yoga for $10. Basic rooms range $105-$210, depending on season (it is open from May to October only).
Read Morefrom New York